1 February 2015.
Our next book is The Husband's Secret, by Australian author Liane Moriarty.
We'll met at Leigha and Steve's place.
Tim brought the shortlist.
Scores:
Cherie (Postal Vote): 16 I won't be there (of course!), but will have to weigh in with a score of 16/17, mostly because of the very satisfying way that everything came together in the end. I read this a few months ago, after finishing What Alice Forgot.
Mari: 6 Pedestrian writing, cloying. Frothy is ok as long as there's coffee underneath. The problem with this book is that there isn't any. It's a babycino. There's not even any chocolate on top.
Jo: 11 It's not going to change my life but I really enjoyed reading it.
Leigha: 10 Finished it, was interested enough to want to see how it ended, but was disappointed that it was so twee.
James: 8 Didn't bother him as much as it did Mari, but it did feel a bit contrived and forced. The ending reinforced this.
Wendy: 14 Enjoyed it. Accepts it is contrived and tied up too neatly at the end but thought the characters were believable.
Maree: 9
Tim: 14
Average: 11.0
Our next book is The Husband's Secret, by Australian author Liane Moriarty.
We'll met at Leigha and Steve's place.
Tim brought the shortlist.
Scores:
Cherie (Postal Vote): 16 I won't be there (of course!), but will have to weigh in with a score of 16/17, mostly because of the very satisfying way that everything came together in the end. I read this a few months ago, after finishing What Alice Forgot.
Mari: 6 Pedestrian writing, cloying. Frothy is ok as long as there's coffee underneath. The problem with this book is that there isn't any. It's a babycino. There's not even any chocolate on top.
Jo: 11 It's not going to change my life but I really enjoyed reading it.
Leigha: 10 Finished it, was interested enough to want to see how it ended, but was disappointed that it was so twee.
James: 8 Didn't bother him as much as it did Mari, but it did feel a bit contrived and forced. The ending reinforced this.
Wendy: 14 Enjoyed it. Accepts it is contrived and tied up too neatly at the end but thought the characters were believable.
Maree: 9
Tim: 14
Average: 11.0
No comments:
Post a Comment